Disabled veteran left unable to attend Remembrance after City estate lift failures

Lars Christensen

A disabled councillor and army veteran says repeated lift outages on the Mansell Street Estate meant he could not attend the Remembrance Sunday service at St Paul’s Cathedral.

A disabled veteran says he was distraught after lift outages on his City of London estate stopped him attending this year’s Remembrance Sunday service at St Paul’s Cathedral.

Deputy John Fletcher, a City of London Corporation councillor who served in the regular and territorial armies for a combined 17 years, uses a wheelchair because of arthritis in most of his joints. He lives on the fourth floor of the Mansell Street Estate in Portsoken, where he needs at least one of the two lifts to be working to get to meetings and other events.

The ongoing problems have led to the London Fire Brigade being called to the estate on several occasions.

Trapped at home when both lifts are out

Deputy Fletcher said he first raised concerns with The Guinness Partnership, which manages the estate, in late August. Since then the problems have continued. He said that if the lifts stop working he would have to go up or down at least one flight of stairs, and his wife would then have to take his electric wheelchair down the stairs, which would take two or three strong men to help. He told the Local Democracy Reporting Service, which is carried by MyLondon, that when both lifts are out he is realistically trapped in his home.

He said the outages have also affected his work as a councillor, where he has missed meetings. He can still work virtually when the lifts are down, but he said there are limits to what he can do from home. He also said repairs were completed, but earlier this week a resident was trapped in a lift again, and the damage done to help that person escape is likely to cost tens of thousands of pounds, which he said would fall on residents through their service charges.

Residents and councillors respond

An anonymous resident said they are scared of using the lifts because of the repeated outages. They said they had once waited 15 minutes for another resident to go in with them.

Fellow Portsoken councillor Jason Pritchard said that residents had endured repeated breakdowns and prolonged outages. He said that when the lifts are out of service, some residents are effectively left housebound. Councillors Munsur Ali and Jason Pritchard have also been working with residents on the issue. Cllr Pritchard said: “Residents deserve better, and this situation cannot be allowed to continue.”

A spokesperson for The Guinness Partnership said lift engineers had been called out a number of times in recent months and had attended within the required timescales to carry out repairs. On the most recent call-out, they said engineers responded within the agreed SLA of 27 minutes, but by then the doors had been damaged beyond repair. New doors are being manufactured, which will take several weeks, and the second lift remains in working order. The spokesperson apologised for the inconvenience and said the company had offered support and temporary accommodation to a resident who uses a wheelchair, as well as a move to another flat when one becomes available, either on the ground floor or on another floor where he would have access to additional lifts.

Latest developments

  1. Guinness præciserer tilbudt flytning til stuen eller en etage med flere elevatorer

See what's on in London

The Jellicoe Lecture with Jake Fiennes
Learning & Networking
23Nov

The Jellicoe Lecture with Jake Fiennes

Monday 23 Nov·15:15
5 Endeavour Square, 5 Endeavour Square, London, E20 1JN
Finsbury
Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions
Arts & Culture
23Nov

Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions

Monday 23 Nov·11:30
Twist Museum, London
MayfairFamily
Guildhall Jazz Showcase – Day 1
Music & Live
23Nov

Guildhall Jazz Showcase – Day 1

Monday 23 Nov·13:45
Vortex Jazz Club, London
Barnsbury
FRAMELESS
Diverse
23Nov

FRAMELESS

Monday 23 Nov·14:30
Marble Arch Place, London
Marylebone
Mum & Baby Barre Fitness for new mothers
Sport & Exercise
23Nov

Mum & Baby Barre Fitness for new mothers

Monday 23 Nov·11:00
Barefoot Yoga & Therapy, London
Elephant and Castle
The View from The Shard
Learning & Networking
23Nov

The View from The Shard

Monday 23 Nov·13:45
The View from The Shard, London
The Borough
Roxhill Trends Summit 2027: journalists on what's trending
Diverse
23Nov

Roxhill Trends Summit 2027: journalists on what's trending

Monday 23 Nov·14:00
St Martin's Lane Hotel, London
Covent Garden
Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions
Arts & Culture
23Nov

Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions

Monday 23 Nov·12:45
Twist Museum, London
MayfairFamily