Hampstead Ponds policy on trans access challenged in High Court

Lars Christensen

The High Court has heard a legal challenge over trans-inclusive access rules at Hampstead Heath’s swimming ponds, with campaigners arguing the policy indirectly discriminates against women.

A High Court judge has heard arguments over the City of London Corporation’s trans-inclusive policy at Hampstead Heath’s swimming ponds in north London.

The case centres on rules allowing trans people to use facilities at the men’s and women’s ponds in line with the gender they identify with. Sex Matters charity is challenging the policy, while the corporation is defending it.

The hearing before Mr Justice Linden is due to conclude on Wednesday, with a written judgment expected later.

What the challenge says

Sex Matters told the court the arrangement puts women at a particular disadvantage compared with men because they are more likely to have their privacy, dignity and sense of safety affected in what they expect to be a single-sex space.

Tom Cross KC, for Sex Matters, told the court: “It is not lawful to exclude persons from one sex but include others of that same sex.”

He also argued that the corporation’s rules are unlawful following the Supreme Court ruling last year that “woman” under the Equality Act means biological woman.

How the City of London Corporation is responding

The City of London Corporation says there have been no substantiated incidents of inappropriate behaviour by a trans person since the policy was introduced in 2017.

In June, the corporation confirmed that the Highgate men’s pond is open to transgender men whose biological sex is female, while transgender women whose biological sex is male can continue to use the Kenwood ladies’ pond. The mixed pond at Hampstead is open to all.

Daniel Stilitz KC, for the corporation, said in written submissions: “There is no evidence before the court of any risk posed by the admission of trans women to the ladies’ pond.”

Facilities and next steps

The corporation says the policy is justified and proportionate, and that a sex-based policy would have changed the character of the ponds and could have led to indirect discrimination claims by trans users.

The court also heard that the ladies’ pond has private facilities for people who do not want to change or shower in a communal space, and that the corporation has spent between £730,000 and £1.08 million improving that provision.

Mr Stilitz also argued that the claim was brought too late, should have been brought in the county court, and that Sex Matters did not have standing to bring the case.

See what's on in London

Tower of London Standard All-Day Entry
Arts & Culture
17Nov

Tower of London Standard All-Day Entry

Tuesday 17 Nov·10:00
Tower Of London
TodayThe Borough
Sustainable Design Mini Forum: round-table discussions on workplace design
Learning & Networking
17Nov

Sustainable Design Mini Forum: round-table discussions on workplace design

Tuesday 17 Nov·16:00
Crypt on the Green, London
TodayClerkenwell
Larger Than Life: Starring Wallace & Gromit, Shaun & More
Arts & Culture
17Nov

Larger Than Life: Starring Wallace & Gromit, Shaun & More

Tuesday 17 Nov·10:00
The Lightroom, London
TodaySomers Town
Pizza party for children at San Pietro
Learning & Networking
17Nov

Pizza party for children at San Pietro

Tuesday 17 Nov·15:45
San Pietro London - Italian Restaurant Kensington
TodayBromptonKids & Youth
Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions
Arts & Culture
17Nov

Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions

Tuesday 17 Nov·16:30
Twist Museum, London
TodayMayfairFamily
Life Drawing at The Bedford, Balham
Learning & Networking
17Nov

Life Drawing at The Bedford, Balham

Tuesday 17 Nov·19:00
The Bedford, London
TodayOval
Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions
Diverse
17Nov

Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions

Tuesday 17 Nov·14:00
Twist Museum, London
TodayMayfairFamily
London Eye - Standard Experience
Learning & Networking
17Nov

London Eye - Standard Experience

Tuesday 17 Nov·10:00
The London Eye
TodayWaterlooFamily