Hampstead Heath cafe owners drop legal fight over Daisy Green takeover

Lars Christensen

The couple behind three independent north London park cafes say they will not continue their court challenge against the City of London Corporation’s decision to hand sites to Daisy Green.

The owners of three independent cafes on Hampstead Heath have dropped their legal challenge over the decision to hand park sites to restaurant chain Daisy Green, writes the Evening Standard.

What is City of London Corporation?

The City of London Corporation is the local authority for the City of London, the historic centre of London. It is based at the Guildhall.

Patrick Matthews and Emma Fernandez said on Monday, 16 November, that they would not pursue judicial review proceedings against the City of London Corporation, despite a judge having granted permission for the claim to go ahead.

The couple run cafes at Parliament Hill Lido, Queen’s Park and Highgate Wood. They had challenged the Corporation’s decision to change operators at sites in Queen’s Park, Golders Hill Park, Parliament Hill Lido and Parliament Hill Fields.

Judge had allowed claim to proceed

In a statement, the couple said their decision had been made with “immense sadness”. They said a judge had reviewed their claim and decided it “was arguable and should be heard”.

The dispute began in December last year, when the City of London Corporation selected Australian-inspired group Daisy Green to run the cafes. The Corporation had said tenancy agreements for the existing operators were ending in February.

The sites were due to be taken over in spring this year. But Matthews and Fernandez continued to run premises at Parliament Hill Lido and Queen’s Park, as well as Highgate Wood.

Corporation had planned eviction action

Earlier this year, lawyers acting for the couple filed a judicial review claim at the High Court. In March, the Corporation, which runs Hampstead Heath as a charity, announced plans to begin possession proceedings to evict Hoxton Beach Ltd from the premises.

The Corporation accused the business of refusing to leave, which it said prevented the new operator from starting fit-outs, building upgrades and improvements.

The couple said: “Ultimately, we cannot continue operating these cafés without the Corporation’s support; the situation is unsustainable. The personal and financial costs have become too great; we have reached the end of the road.”

Campaign drew celebrity backing

The fight over the cafes drew support from actors Benedict Cumberbatch and James McAvoy. A petition calling for the handover to be stopped was signed by 24,000 people.

The couple also said they wished the new operator well and were ready to work constructively with the Corporation on the outcome for those affected, including staff and colleagues.

Daisy Green already runs cafes in London, including sites on Regent Street, in Soho, Victoria, Paddington and Richmond.

See what's on in London

Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions
Diverse
17Nov

Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions

Tuesday 17 Nov·10:00
Twist Museum, London
TodayMayfairFamily
NextGen Intelligence Conference: Data, Cloud and AI
Learning & Networking
16Nov

NextGen Intelligence Conference: Data, Cloud and AI

Monday 16 Nov·09:00
Holiday Inn Express London - Greenwich by IHG
Walworth
eCommerce, eBay and Amazon Networking Evening
Learning & Networking
17Nov

eCommerce, eBay and Amazon Networking Evening

Tuesday 17 Nov·18:30
Qibo Skybar, London
TodayWalworth
Kemper System Liquid Waterproofing Contractor Training
Learning & Networking
17Nov

Kemper System Liquid Waterproofing Contractor Training

Tuesday 17 Nov·08:30
JJ Roofing Supplies Training Academy, London
TodayPaddington
West London People Planet Pint: Sustainability Meetup
Learning & Networking
17Nov

West London People Planet Pint: Sustainability Meetup

Tuesday 17 Nov·18:00
Defectors Weld, London
TodayChristmasBrompton
FRAMELESS
Diverse
17Nov

FRAMELESS

Tuesday 17 Nov·12:00
Marble Arch Place, London
TodayMarylebone
Data Connect London: data and AI in practice
Learning & Networking
17Nov

Data Connect London: data and AI in practice

Tuesday 17 Nov·09:00
Lumiere London Underwood Flagship Venue
TodayFinsbury
Evening yoga at Tooting Bec Lido
Sport & Exercise
17Nov

Evening yoga at Tooting Bec Lido

Tuesday 17 Nov·18:45
Tooting Bec Lido, London
TodayOval