Driver overturns £160 yellow box fine after tribunal ruling in London

Marc Kastholm

A London driver successfully challenged a £160 yellow box junction fine after an independent tribunal found the section where she stopped went beyond what was legally required.

A driver has had a £160 yellow box junction fine cancelled after an independent adjudicator ruled that part of the road marking in Plumstead was larger than the law requires.

The case centred on the junction of Plumstead High Street and Garibaldi Street in south-east London. London Tribunals found the driver had stopped in the section of the yellow box beyond the far end of the junction, and ruled that “the box junction is not substantially compliant with the legislative procedures”.

The decision followed a six-month appeal process after Greenwich Council rejected the motorist’s initial challenge.

Why the appeal succeeded

Yellow box junctions are meant to stop vehicles blocking crossings and keep traffic moving. In London, drivers can be fined £160, reduced to £80 if paid within 14 days, if cameras catch them entering and stopping in one.

In this case, the woman contacted traffic campaigner Sam Wright for help after being fined for stopping in the box for three seconds. Wright then helped take the case to London Tribunals, the independent body that deals with these penalty charge notices.

The tribunal decided that video evidence showed the yellow box extended beyond the junction itself. Under the Traffic Signs Regulations and General Directions 2016, box junctions can be placed at a junction between two or more roads, as well as at roundabouts and near emergency service entrances.

Nearly £750,000 in fines issued

After the ruling, Wright submitted a Freedom of Information request to Greenwich Council asking how much money had been raised from enforcement at the junction since it began.

The council said that between 7 September 2021 and 30 September 2026, 11,950 penalty charge notices were issued there, with a total monetary value of £741,461.

Wright, a former traffic engineer at Transport for London, criticised the design and enforcement of the junction. He told MyLondon: “It’s not just about the box length. It’s the fact that she stopped for three seconds. You’re giving tickets to people and it’s putting them through a lot of stress. It’s really horrible.”

Council says junction helps emergency services

Greenwich Council rejected the suggestion that the junction was being used to raise money. It said the yellow box helps keep the carriageway clear so emergency services can respond more quickly, with both a police station and fire station close to Garibaldi Street.

Cllr Calum O’Byrne Mulligan, Greenwich’s Cabinet Member for Transport, Climate Change, Waste and Streets, said: “Keeping this area clear is essential to helping emergency services get out quickly and respond to incidents without unnecessary delays.”

He also said the council did not agree with the tribunal’s reasoning in the individual case, but chose not to contest the appeal. The council added that it would review locations where there is evidence that changes may be needed.

See what's on in London

Middle Temple Hall Lunch & Tours
Learning & Networking
17Nov

Middle Temple Hall Lunch & Tours

Tuesday 17 Nov·12:00
Middle Temple Hall, London
TodayCovent Garden
Elif Shafak on the Power of Storytelling
Learning & Networking
17Nov

Elif Shafak on the Power of Storytelling

Tuesday 17 Nov·18:30
RSA House, London
TodayCovent Garden
Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions
Diverse
17Nov

Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions

Tuesday 17 Nov·10:00
Twist Museum, London
TodayMayfairFamily
Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions
Diverse
17Nov

Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions

Tuesday 17 Nov·18:15
Twist Museum, London
TodayMayfairFamily
Level UP - Beginner Acting Workshop
Learning & Networking
17Nov

Level UP - Beginner Acting Workshop

Tuesday 17 Nov·19:00
Good Hotel, Western Gateway, London, E16 1FA
TodayThe BoroughEveryone
ESCP London Fundraising Gala Dinner 2026
Learning & Networking
17Nov

ESCP London Fundraising Gala Dinner 2026

Tuesday 17 Nov·19:00
The Royal Automobile Club, London
TodaySoho
Media, PR & Communications Business Networking Evening
Learning & Networking
17Nov

Media, PR & Communications Business Networking Evening

Tuesday 17 Nov·18:00
The Coach House, London
TodaySoho
Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions
Diverse
17Nov

Twist Museum: London's Home of Illusions

Tuesday 17 Nov·12:00
Twist Museum, London
TodayMayfairFamily